Lack Of Progress Tests The Limits Of Trump's Immigration Strategy

WASHINGTON — In the Trump era, there's been a tendency to think about immigration policy as a political football. A cudgel. A weapon.

The president has certainly treated it as such. Just look at his latest proposal to transport undocumented immigrants to sanctuary cities as political retribution to Democrats — and his suggestion that his immigration opponents are "treasonous."

But if you look at immigration instead as a problem to be solved — more like health care — it may be a much better way to understand the long-term political risks of using the immigration issue to divide the electorate.

Trump and the GOP have hammered away at an immigration status quo they say doesn't work. But Trump's proposals to fix it have been politically unviable (the wall), legally untenable (denying the right to seek asylum), economically risky (closing the border), or the cause of public moral outrage (family separation.)

So, Trump has mostly been left with grievances. And griping about a system that doesn't work can only get you so far politically.

Just look at what happened with health care.

Republicans had great success in the 2010 and 2014 midterms picking apart Obamacare's flaws. But by 2018, Democrats clobbered them by running as the party that would fix the problems, after Republicans failed to come up with a workable alternative.

Sure, immigration is the defining issue for much of Trump's base. And there's certainly a chunk of his voters who will always stick with him on the grievances alone.

But in the middle of the electorate, voters — especially independents — are going to want to see progress.

And they're likely to reward candidates who seem to be taking solutions seriously.

>New Barr ruling withholds bail for asylum seekers

Speaking of immigration policy, here's the latest from NBC's Julia Ainsley and Doha Madani on a new decision from AG William Barr:

"In his decision, Barr said that asylum seekers who begin in expedited removal, in which they are not given the right to see a judge, and are then transferred to full removal proceedings, in which they wait to make their case before a judge, should not be released on bond."

More: "It means that thousands of asylum seekers who once would have been out on bond and living in the U.S. while awaiting a decision on their status will now be kept in detention centers, where the wait times are climbing from months to a year."

>2020 Vision: Sanders catches Trump's eye on Fox News

Trump is trying his hand at some 2020 punditry again after Bernie Sanders participated in a Fox News town hall Monday.

The president tweeted about Sanders' appearance and speculated that the Democratic race will come down to "Crazy Bernie Sanders and Sleepy Joe Biden."

Lack of progress tests the limits of Trump's immigration strategy
Trump’s big, early lead in Facebook ads deeply worries Democratic strategists
The flow of guns from the U.S. to Mexico is getting lost in the border debate
POLITICO Playbook: Welcome to debate week
Trump, sumo and the limits of strategic flattery
The Two Trump Traits That Led to the Shutdown
Trump’s plan to overhaul legal immigration draws cool reception
Trump’s Immigration Plan Imposes Radical New Income and Health Tests
Trump declares border emergency, testing the limits of presidential authority
Travel-ban ruling could embolden Trump in remaking the U.S. immigration system